Sex Contextualist Frameworks

Proposed by Sarah S. Richardson in her 2022 paper, sex contextualism is a framework for operationalizing and analyzing sex in a way that attends to its pluralist, context-specific forms across biomedical research. We offer a beginner-friendly teaching slide deck and research handout to equip researchers, educators, and students with critical tools for understanding sex contextualism as a meaningful conceptual and practical framework.

Sex Contextualism

SUGGESTED PAPER CITATION

Richardson, S. S. (2022). Sex contextualism. Philosophy, Theory, and Practice in Biology, 14, Article 2. https://doi.org/10.3998/ptpbio.2096ttps://doi.org/10.3998/ptpbio.209


Teaching Slide Deck

The following slidedeck:

  • addresses the motivation for, and pitfalls of, attending to sex-related variation;

  • explains sex contextualism in contrast to sex essentialism;

  • touches on the practical implications for laboratory scientists.

It suits intro biology, feminist science studies, and philosophy of biology classes, and other teaching settings.

SUGGESTED GENERAL SLIDE DECK CITATION

GenderSci Lab. (2022, April). Sex contextualism: Teaching slidedeck by Harvard University’s GenderSci Lab. https://www.genderscilab.org/gendersci-lab-methods-toolkit

Using the slides: please don’t alter them after download. If you use only a portion, keep the GenderSci Lab logo and cite appropriately.

STATEMENT OF INTELLECTUAL LABOR

Sarah Richardson wrote this teaching module using materials from her own presentations and a presentation that Marina DiMarco, Mia Miyagi, and Kelsey Ichikawa created. Kelsey Ichikawa formatted and captioned the module and wrote this blog introduction that this teaching module took inspiration from.

FOR CITING SELECTED SLIDES ONLY

GenderSci Lab. (2022, April). Sex contextualism: Teaching slidedeck by Harvard University’s GenderSci Lab (Slides x, y, z). https://www.genderscilab.org/gendersci-lab-methods-toolkit

Research Handout for Scientists

The following research handout is a condensed, portable, 1-page document that answers common questions about sex contextualist approaches in experimental design, execution, and reporting. We invite you to read it over and share it with other researchers.

SUGGESTED HANDOUT CITATION

Miyagi, M. (2022, April 11). When and how can you apply sex contextualism in your own research? GenderSci Lab. https://www.genderscilab.org/gendersci-lab-methods-toolkit

STATEMENT OF INTELLECTUAL LABOR

Mia Miyagi conceived of, wrote, and revised the document. Sarah Richardson, Marion Boulicault, Kelsey Ichikawa, and Heather Shattuck-Heidorn contributed edits and revision feedback.


Sex Essentialist vs. Sex Contextualist Frameworks

Two ways to conceptualize sex as a biological variable, as contrasted in Table 1 of Richardson’s sex contextualism paper.

CENTRAL CONCERN

Studies using material from one sex may not generalize to the other.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OMNIPRESENCE

Every biological system and material has a sexual identity, male or female.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

POLICY GUIDANCE

Include male and female subjects or material and report differences between the two groups.

Sex Essentialism

CENTRAL CONCERN

Sex-related variables produce variation between and within sex-defined classes, depending on context. Male–female findings may not generalize to all males and females, or across species.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

OMNIPRESENCE

The presence of sex-related biological variables in a material does not entail a causal relation to sex-specific biology, nor does it necessarily warrant a definitive label of “male” or “female” sex to that material.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

POLICY GUIDANCE

Consider sex-related variation within a well-specified research context; male–female comparison may be neither necessary nor sufficient in capturing sex-related biological variation.

Sex Contextualism

How to Apply Sex Contextualism:

Before you operationalize sex, be explicit about what you mean.

  • Which sex-related material factors (hormonal milieu, gonadal anatomy, developmental pathway) am I actually studying?

  • Are my subclasses discrete or continuous, and how many are there?

Step 1

Define it

Explain why this operationalization fits your context.

  • Does it fit my species or strain, developmental stage, and level of analysis (cell, tissue, organism)?

  • Is male–female comparison apt here, or is another grouping (e.g., estrogen level) a better fit?

Step 2

Justify it

Ask what your sex-related finding can and can’t support.

  • Would it generalize across model systems, species, or to humans?

  • Could lab conditions (caging, diet, observer sex, cycle stage) be mediating it?

Step 3

Test its limits

Sex Contextualism Frequently Asked Questions