Gender/Sex Disparities in COVID-19 Outcomes
Data suggest that, in aggregate, men died from COVID-19 at higher rates than women during the pandemic. How can we interpret and make sense of this disparity? This analytical toolkit provides resources for unpacking and understanding apparent sex disparities in COVID-19 outcomes. Students are challenged to think critically about the causal primacy granted to biological sex in attempts to explain the gender/sex gap in COVID-19 mortality. Additionally, the toolkit offers a variety of social and demographic factors as alternative ways of understanding, investigating, and talking about inequities in the COVID-19 pandemic.
STATEMENT OF INTELLECTUAL LABOR
The “Gender/Sex Disparities in COVID-19 Outcomes” teaching tools grew out of our Gender/Sex and COVID-19 Project, and reflect months of research and labor by the whole lab. Ann-Caroline Danielsen conceived and led the teaching tool project, drawing up the initial draft, integrating lab member comments and edits during the revision process, and drafting the guide and blog post, in close collaboration with Sarah Richardson and Heather Shattuck-Heidorn, who advised the project. Capri D’Souza, Nicole Noll, Mimi Tarrant, and Helen Zhao helped develop the overall plan and objectives of the teaching project. Many people contributed to the content, visual design, and drafting and revision process, including Danielsen, Richardson, Shattuck-Heidorn, Marion Boulicault, D’Souza, Annika Gompers, Katie Jillson, Noll, Meg Perret, Tamara Rushovich, Tarrant, and Zhao. Juanis Becerra helped format the final presentation and developed a dissemination plan for the teaching tool.
Introduction and User Guide
The user guide provides an introduction to the teaching materials and specific guidance for instructors for adapting the teaching presentation to different classroom contexts and conducting breakout activities. A detailed presentation outline, terminology guide, and timing estimates for each section of the presentation are included in the user guide. We also offer suggestions for assigned readings to pair with the presentation.
SUGGESTED USER GUIDE CITATION
GenderSci Lab. (2020). Introduction and user guide. https://www.genderscilab.org/gendersci-lab-methods-toolkit
Teaching Slide Deck
The teaching presentation provides an analytical toolkit for unpacking apparent sex disparities in COVID-19 outcomes. The presentation leads students through a series of questions about the causal primacy granted to biological sex in attempts to explain the gender/sex gap in COVID-19 mortality. Gender and other social and demographic factors are offered as an alternative way of understanding, investigating, and talking about inequities in the COVID-19 pandemic.
Data and case examples are drawn from the United States, but the analytical principles illustrated in the teaching toolkit can be applied to query sex disparities in COVID-19 outcomes in other contexts.
SUGGESTED GENERAL SLIDE DECK CITATION
GenderSci Lab. (2020). Gender/sex disparities in COVID-19 outcomes: A guide and toolkit by Harvard University’s GenderSci Lab. https://www.genderscilab.org/gendersci-lab-methods-toolkit
FOR CITING SELECTED SLIDES ONLY
GenderSci Lab. (2020). Gender/sex disparities in COVID-19 outcomes: A guide and toolkit by Harvard University’s GenderSci Lab (Slides x, y, z). https://www.genderscilab.org/gendersci-lab-methods-toolkit
Using the slides: please don’t alter them after download. If you use only a portion, keep the GenderSci Lab logo and cite appropriately.
STATEMENT OF INTELLECTUAL LABOR
Sarah Richardson wrote this teaching module using materials from her own presentations and a presentation that Marina DiMarco, Mia Miyagi, and Kelsey Ichikawa created. Kelsey Ichikawa formatted and captioned the module and wrote the blog introduction that this teaching module took inspiration from.
Why teach about COVID-19 sex
disparities through a critical lens?
A focus on biological sex may underplay the contribution of gender-related and other social factors to COVID-19 disparities, misdirecting public health efforts. An additional concern is that decontextualized statistics about sex differences in cases and deaths from COVID-19 can reinforce biological sex-essentialist stereotypes.
Both biological and social factors, and interactions between the two, may play a role in shaping the observed patterns of COVID-19 outcomes. Discussions of sex disparities in COVID-19 outcomes often emphasize biological factors, even suggesting differential treatment avenues or vaccine regimes for individuals of different sexes. However, as this presentation emphasizes, evidence from prior infectious disease epidemics, including closely-related coronaviruses, demonstrates that gendered factors such as occupation, lifestyle, and comorbidities, along with interacting social variables such as racism and socioeconomic class are likely the primary contributors to apparent sex disparities in COVID-19.
Learning Objectives
Appreciate the social dimensions of inequities in the distribution of COVID-19 outcomes.
Understand the distinction between sex and gender and appreciate how sex interacts with gender and other social and demographic factors to produce sex disparities in health outcomes.
Gain applied, practical experience analyzing scientific claims about biological sex differences in an intersectional framework in the context of the pandemic.
Recognize that data do not speak for themselves and that theory, language, and social positionality influence our interpretation of data.
Primary
Gain awareness of the assumptions that are commonly made about the causes of sex differences, namely about the primacy of biological sex over other biological and social factors.
Critically evaluate public discourse and news reporting on COVID-19 inequities.
Evaluate public health and public policy priorities for addressing social and gendered vulnerabilities in the COVID-19 epidemic.
Secondary
How to Use the Toolkit
Given the adaptable nature of this toolkit, timing estimates are provided separately for lecture slides and breakout activities.
The total speaking length of the presentation is approximately 40 minutes. The toolkit has been designed to allow for adaptation to different classroom contexts and is written for introductory and interdisciplinary audiences across the humanities, social sciences, and sciences. The slide presentation consists of an introduction and three self-contained units (Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3) that can be taught together or independently of each other. The introduction should always be covered in class. Once the introduction is covered, instructors can choose to focus on any of the three self-contained units without losing internal consistency.
The toolkit also suggests a number of small-group breakout activities to promote active learning and participation. Each of the four break-out activities can be completed in approximately 15-20 minutes. This structure encourages critical thinking about the interpretation of scientific data and social categories. The breakout activity slides are clearly flagged: instructors are encouraged to select the breakout activities that best suit the needs of their students or the structure of their course.
Suggested Assigned Readings
Shattuck-Heidorn, H., Reiches, M. W., & Richardson, S. S. (2020, June 24). What’s really behind the gender gap in COVID-19 deaths? The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/24/opinion/sex-differences-covid.html.
Danielsen, A. C., & Noll, N. E. (2020, June 24). Communicating about COVID-19 and sex disparities: A guide for media, scientists, public health officials, and educators. GenderSci Blog. https://www.genderscilab.org/blog/covid-communication.
Chotiner, I. (2020, April 14). Interview with Dr. Nancy Krieger: The interwoven threads of inequality and health. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/news/q-and-a/the-coronavirus-and-the-interwoven-threads-of-inequality-and-health.
Islam, N., Khunti, K., Dambha-Miller, H., Kawachi, I., & Marmot, M. (2020). COVID-19 mortality: A complex interplay of sex, gender and ethnicity. European Journal of Public Health. https://academic.oup.com/eurpub/advance-article/doi/10.1093/eurpub/ckaa150/5879989.
Companion Resources
April 13, 2020 to November 29, 2021 · 50 states and 2 territories
Weekly and cumulative sex-disaggregated cases and deaths, manually extracted from state health departments. Includes case and mortality rates, age-adjusted rates, a time series, and a full data table.
Archived
US Gender/Sex COVID-19 Data Tracker
Launched July 2020 · Health Affairs Blog
Grades states on the social and demographic detail in their surveillance reporting. The April 2021 rubric scores fatalities, hospitalizations, and vaccinations across five variables (15 points).
Archived
US State COVID-19 Report Card
COVID-19 Gender/Sex Disparities Frequently Asked Questions
-
No. Cover the introduction, then choose any of the three units, alone or together, plus whichever breakouts suit your course.
-
No. It reported data from April 2020 to November 2021 and is kept as an archive for teaching and research.
-
Yes. The data and cases used are from the U.S., but the analytical principles can be applied to gender/sex disparities in other contexts.
-
Please use the slides as downloaded, and retain the logo and cite if using only some slides.